catdaddyp
-
Posts
2,381 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
99
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Blogs
Posts posted by catdaddyp
-
-
13 minutes ago, LZIp said:
Under the assumption we are favorites vs Kent and umASS (though there is no such thing as a penciled in win for us), can we get 2 out of the 4 vs Ball St, Buffalo, Miami, and BG to get to 6?
Assuming we stay relatively healthy, it’s possible. I feel like the toughest game left on the schedule is Miami — they’re better than their record indicates with Finn leading the charge. Ball State seems to be playing above their talent level right now, so that one’s probably a toss-up. I haven’t been impressed with Buffalo; they beat Kent by three and EMU by one in overtime. BG still can’t seem to figure out what they are offensively, and we tend to play our best football at the end of the season under this staff.
-
-
-
QB:
Finley had his best game of the season, and if he’d played like that against Wyoming, we’d probably be sitting here with another win. Granted, CMU’s defense wasn’t anything special — I thought the number of turnovers they’d created (or been gifted) coming in masked some of their flaws. Still, it was great to finally see the kind of performance we know Finley is capable of. Hopefully, that’s something he can build on moving forward. On the lone interception, it looked like there was some sort of miscommunication, with the receiver running a different route than what Finley expected.
RB:
I don’t have enough positive things to say about Gant. He was excellent and once again looked like the FCS All-American from a few years back. He seemed a little gassed in the fourth quarter — which is understandable given he carried the ball 32 times and was on the field for all but six offensive snaps. It would’ve been nice to have another playmaker like Patrick available to give him a breather, but that wasn’t an option. Curry saw his first action, and while he’s a bigger back, he didn’t have much of a chance to show what he can do in limited touches.
WR:
Mason finally had the breakout game I’ve been waiting for. His performance looked a lot like what he showed during the spring game — the flashes that had me raving about him during the offseason. Outside of one glaring drop that would’ve moved the chains, this group was solid, and that miscue didn’t end up costing us. We just need this unit to keep developing. If they do, we’ll be talking about one of the better wide receiver corps in the MAC by the end of the season.
TE:
All three tight ends caught passes today and chipped in with some key blocks as well. I’m not sure why PFF graded the group as low as they did — I actually thought they played a sound game all-around.
OL:
This was one of the offensive line’s best games of the season — especially in the run game. It wasn’t perfect by any means, but they did enough to give the offense a chance to be effective in both phases. I believe K. Davis played every snap at right guard, which says a lot about his reliability and consistency up front.
DL:
I’m not sure when the last time our defense had five sacks, with four of them coming from the defensive line. Laventure was credited with six total pressures and two sacks, while Durham had two sacks, and Dall had three pressures. I also want to give credit to the DL for holding their ground and blowing up running lanes so often.
LB:
Summers played a whale of a game. I’m not sure what the refs thought they heard when he was flagged for mimicking calls again, but from my view, it looked like he was just trying to get everyone lined up correctly on a play where several defenders seemed unsure of their assignments.
I’ll lump the secondary into this as well — it’s tough to always be in the right spot and still make open-field tackles against an offense like CMU’s, one that relies heavily on misdirection and gets its linemen to the second level. There were more busts than anyone would like to see, but overall the defense did enough to slow CMU down when it mattered most.
DB:
The secondary was asked to play the run more in this game than any other so far this season — as alluded to above. In coverage, they were generally solid, holding CMU to just 136 yards through the air. No individual stood out in a negative way, which is definitely a positive sign.
ST:
Special teams were very good overall, outside of the long missed field goal — which came from a tough angle — and Hills overestimating his ability by bringing out kicks several yards deep in the end zone. I like Hills and still think he’s going to break one this year, but there’s just no reason to bring those out from that deep.
Coaching:
Give credit where credit is due — great gameplans on both sides of the ball. Offensively, we were stubborn running the football while also taking timely shots downfield. The defense looked well prepared and didn’t hang their heads after giving up some explosive plays. Overall, I thought the staff came close to maximizing what they could in this game. The only downside was a handful of penalties that were 100% self-inflicted.
QB:
Finley
Johnson
RB:
Gant
Curry
WR:
Walker
Masom
WR:
Mar. Williams
Grear
WR:
Polk
Monteiro
TE:
Newell
Cravaack
Whisner
LT:
Dar. Johnson
Motley-Simmons
LG:
McManus
Archer
C
Lyons
Morris
RG:
K. Davis
RT:
King
A. Jones
DE:
Durham
D. Frazier
DE:
Dall
J. Frazier
DT:
Hull
Murphy
Musika
DT:
Laventure
Mixon
Madden
LB:
Summers
Boswell
LB:
Cooper
Spriggs
NB:
Al. Branch
CB:
Reed
Kamara
CB:
DeWalt
Thomas
S:
Flowers
Hunter
S:
Di. Johnson
Stepney
Top Rated on Offense (20 snap min.)
WR - Mason
C - Lyons
QB - Finley
RG - K. Davis
RB - Gant
Top Rated on Defense (20 snap min.)
LB - Summers
S - Flowers
LB - Spriggs
CB - DeWalt
CB - Reed
-
6
-
3
-
1
-
-
Game Day Notes:
CMU has rotated quarterbacks for much of the year but seems to have settled on Labas and Flores. When Labas is under center, they throw it about 65% of the time, while Flores’ snaps are heavily run-oriented — 81% of his plays have been runs.
Outside of Flores, Biggins and Cornist have handled most of the work on the ground, each averaging over four yards per carry. Biggins has also been a reliable option as a receiver out of the backfield.
In the passing game, McIntosh and Lewis are the primary threats, while tight end DeCorian Temple is a name to keep an eye on in the red zone.
Whether it’s more about scheme or personnel, this offensive line is noticeably stronger in the run game than in pass protection. If the Chips think they can establish the run against an opponent, they’ll lean into it — and the passing game will take a back seat.
Most of CMU’s pass rush comes from one source — defensive end Michael Heldman. No one else on the roster has come close to matching the kind of pressure he’s generated in 2025. While CMU doesn’t boast an elite defense and has been about average overall, the unit has tackled well.
Despite the overall record, we’ve got a few players who are tracking toward all-conference seasons — RG Davis, DE Dall, LB Cooper, CB DeWalt, and CB Reed. Hopefully the team can bounce back today and put together a strong performance against an opponent that’s very beatable, as long as we stay within striking distance.
-
1
-
-
-
-
I agree the program is in trouble without any NIL resources. If nothing changes, we’re basically going to turn into a developmental team for programs that do have them. We were tied for the most MAC players lost to Power programs this past offseason, and on top of that we lost highly productive guys like Norton, T. Williams, and G. Smith to other G5 schools. The staff has done an excellent job identifying talent, bringing those kids in, and developing a large portion of them, but the reality is we won’t be able to keep them for long with the way the current landscape is moving. On top of that, I don’t think our win total has matched the talent level we’ve built over the last few years.
I was staunchly against the idea of moving to FCS. While that might solve a monetary deficit — and I can’t really speak to the numbers there — it’s certainly not guaranteed to field a more competitive product. Outside of Nebraska and Toledo, this team has been competitive, they just haven’t won, and that should rightfully sit uneasy with fans and stakeholders. My biggest issue with this year’s team has been quarterback play. Our starter hasn’t played up to his potential, and we don’t have a backup capable of keeping us in a game. How that’s the case in year four is beyond me. The defense had a terrible day as well, which just made things look that much worse.
Back to the FCS conversation — I believe a split is coming with the haves and have-nots anyway, so we’ll end up being forced into a different division organically. Who knows what that will look like, but the SEC and Big Ten are in the driver’s seat while the NCAA loses more control by the day.
I certainly don’t mean to turn this thread into one we basically already have going elsewhere, since none of us truly know what’s going to happen in the coming years and can only guess. That said, I thought I’d chime in because it does relate to our results this season and where the program is headed if nothing changes. Even so, I still believe we have enough talent to hang with every team left on our schedule, and I’m not giving this staff a free pass. We need to see better performances and results.
-
1
-
-
There’s not a whole lot to be said about this one. As we’ve discussed before, this year’s offense goes as Finley goes. No Finley means no offense. Add in Patrick being out and our chances of competing dropped even more. I’m not sure why Finley didn’t play, but Johnson seemed like he was running a limited package in the first half. Toledo caught on quickly to what we were trying to do, and Johnson’s accuracy issues showed up again. Roggow throws it much better than Johnson, but he seems a ways off in terms of reading college defenses.
The defense doesn’t get a pass either. There were way too many busts and missed tackles, even from guys who’ve been steady all year. Just one of those bad days at the office.
We needed to be at our best to have a shot today, and that didn’t come close to happening. Now it’s about turning the page and gearing up for a physical — and potentially winnable — matchup with CMU next week.
QB:
Johnson
Roggow
HB:
Gant
M. Williams
Macon
Reed
WR:
Walker
Mason
WR:
Polk
Grear
WR:
Mar. Williams
Monteiron
TE:
Newell
Cravaack
LT:
D. Johnson
Morley-Simmons
LG:
McManus
Archer
C
Lyons
Morris
RG:
K. Davis
Archer
RT:
A. Jones
King
DE:
Durham
J. Frazier
Brown
DE:
Dall
D. Frazier
DT:
Hull
Murphy
Musika
DT:
Laventure
Mixon
Madden
LB:
Cooper
Spriggs
Benenge
LB:
Boswell
Hocker
NB:
AL. Branch
AA. Branch
CB:
DeWalt
Kamara
CB:
Reed
T. Thomas
S:
Flowers
Hunter
S:
DI. Johnson
Stepney
Wondolowski
Top Offense (20 snap minimum):
RT - King
OG - Archer
RB - Gant
WR - Polk
WR - Monteiro
Top Defense (20 snap minimum):
DT - Hull
LB - Spriggs
S - Flowers
DT - Laventure
CB - T. Thomas
-
1
-
-
Game Day Notes:
TOLEDO:
Quarterback Tucker Gleason has been steady or better in every outing this year except for the WMU game, where he just wasn’t very good. As you’d expect, plenty of Rocket fans were calling for their backup, “JAR,” to ride in and save the day, but that moment never came.
Kentucky transfer Chip Trayanum has been a force in the backfield, piling up 401 yards and 5 touchdowns already.
Toledo probably boasts the most talented wide receiver group in the MAC, but the offense has leaned heavily on the ground game—even with a difference-maker like Junior Vandeross split out wide. A big piece of that is the offensive line, which has had its fair share of struggles protecting the passer.
The Rockets currently sport the best defense in the conference and have only given up 14.8 points per game.
Linebacker K’Von Sherman (former JUCO) leads the Rockets in tackles with 30 total. I thought Sherman was the best linebacker recruit in the 2024 MAC class when it came to Rivals’ HS/JUCO classification.
At this point, everyone knows who’s been playing well and who hasn’t for Akron, so I won’t harp on that going into this matchup. What I’ll be watching for is pretty straightforward:
Can we move the ball with any kind of efficiency against what looks like the best defense we’ll face outside of Nebraska?
Can we slow down the run, force the Rockets to throw, and generate pressure against a line that’s been shaky in pass protection?
And lastly, field position feels like it’s going to be huge—where drives start could end up being the difference in whether we have a shot at pulling this one off.
-
2
-
-
-
-
QB:
Most of the criticism I have from yesterday’s game could be viewed as nitpicking, but there are still a few concerns. Finley played fine overall, but he wasn’t as consistently accurate as I expected given that he faced no real pressure and a secondary that’s struggled this year. Maybe he’s still working on timing with some of the receivers, but we’re four games in now and they’ve had all summer and fall camp to get on the same page. The interception he threw was eerily similar to one earlier in the season where he also failed to recognize a linebacker sitting underneath.
Johnson was used in nearly every short-yardage situation and, from what I recall, converted at a 100% rate. He also got several series as the true backup quarterback. His throwing motion is noticeably different than Bullock’s, but his accuracy looks to be about the same. That said, the playbook seemed a bit restricted during his time on the field.
Roggow got a series with the starting offensive line and did some nice things for a redshirt freshman. I was hoping we’d see Broughton as well, but he didn’t get any snaps.
RB:
Gant looks fully healthy now and more like the player he was at Tennessee State. He’s a patient runner who gets downhill in a hurry once he picks his spot, and we’ve seen it two weeks in a row now. Against UAB it showed, and this week he finished with 161 yards and 3 touchdowns, with 69 of those yards coming after contact. He averaged an eye-popping 12.4 yards per carry.
Patrick had a few moments where it felt like he was close to breaking a big one, but similar to last week, he was kept from many explosive plays. Even so, he still averaged 4.7 yards per carry and added two catches for 34 yards.
M. Williams got a few carries in mop-up duty, as did some walk-ons. I also noticed Colgate transfer Chris Gee was still not dressed out. Not sure what his status is for the year, but if he can get healthy, he could provide a nice power element to the backfield.
WR:
The receivers created separation all game, but the frustrating part is they still had three drops. I still believe this is the most talented group of receivers since Moorhead’s arrival, and hopefully they start living up to that assessment soon. Through four games the corps has already been credited with 14 drops. The drops were manageable against a team like Duquesne, but won’t cut it once conference play begins.
Adams saw the field in a backup role but didn’t have a ball come his way.
TE:
Newell and Cravaack mostly had their way up front against the Dukes. Duquesne clearly made it a priority to take the tight ends out of the passing game, with Cravaack getting the only reception of the night.
OL:
The offensive line dominated what was supposed to be a strong FCS defensive front. They opened up plenty of room for the run game and didn’t allow a single sack. In fact, they surrendered only five pressures all night, even with the backups in. That hasn’t always been the case against FCS opponents during Moorhead’s tenure.
DL:
The defense completely dominated outside of two busted runs that went for 74 and 34 yards. Dall was nearly unblockable, piling up a sack, six hurries, and another pass defensed. At some point, opposing offenses are going to realize Dall and Laventure are the only two linemen consistently winning their one-on-ones in the passing game and start adjusting their protection to deal with it.
LB:
Cooper and Boswell got the start, while Summers wasn’t dressed—I’m not sure if that was injury-related or a disciplinary matter. I thought Cooper, Boswell, and Spriggs formed a solid trio. Hocker and Benenge got some run late in the game.
DB:
Cornerback play was excellent, but safety play left something to be desired. I’m pretty sure it was Hunter who flat out missed two tackles in the open field. He’ll bounce back, but it’s worth noting he had some struggles against UAB too. What really stood out, though, was how physical our secondary was against Duquesne’s receivers. Reed, DeWalt, and Kamara definitely looked the part.
ST:
Special teams were excellent in every phase. Not much else to say here.
Final Thoughts:
Akron actually looked the part of an FBS team against an FCS opponent, with just about everything clicking on offense and the defense having its way. That hasn’t always been the case, so it was good to see the Zips handle a game I thought would be a little more competitive. Both lines of scrimmage were controlled, and this should serve as a confidence boost heading into conference play.
QB:
Finley
Johnson
Roggow
Brookhart
HB:
Patrick
Gant
M. Williams
Reed
Macon
WR:
Walker
Mason
Louis
WR:
M. Williams
Grear
Monteiron
Witherspoon
Hazuda
WR:
Polk
Adams
Hills
TE:
Newell
Cravaack
Whisner
LT:
Motley-Simmons
D. Johnson
Mann
LG:
Archer
McManus
Fox
George
C
Lyons
Morris
Mobley
RG:
K. Davis
Archer
RT:
A. Jones
King
Ndaiga
DE:
Dall
J. Frazier
DE:
Durham
D. Frazier
Murphy
DT:
Hull
Murphy
Musika
DT:
Laventure
Mixon
LB:
Cooper
Spriggs
LB:
Boswell
Benenge
Hocker
NB:
Al. Branch
AA. Branch
Wondolowski
CB:
Reed
Kamara
K. Johnson
CB:
DeWalt
T. Thomas
S:
Hunter
Somerville
Stepney
S:
Di. Johnson
Flowers
T. Davis
Top Rated Offense (20 snap minimum)
HB - Gant
RT - A. Jones
LT - Morley-Simmons
WR - Walker
LT - D. Johnson
Top Rated Defense (20 snap minimum)
CB - DeWalt
CB - Kamara
LB - Cooper
DE - Dall
CB - T. Thomas
-
2
-
-
GAME DAY NOTES:
Duquesne
Offense:Tyler Riddell is the starting quarterback after previous stops at East Tennessee State and Gardner-Webb. He’s thrown for 604 yards with eight touchdowns against just one interception.
The run game has been more of an afterthought, as the top two backs have combined for only 42 carries through three games.
Barring injury, Joey Isabella looks like a lock for another all-conference season, already putting up 319 yards and three touchdowns on 22 receptions. No other receiver has more than seven catches.
Up front, the offensive line has surrendered six sacks, though four of those came in one game against Pittsburgh. Left tackle Brian Beidatsch has stood out.
Defense:
Jack Dunkley has been a force off the edge, while Maine transfer linebacker Jabari Odoemenem has been one of the Dukes’ best players, leading the team with 20 tackles.
The secondary hasn’t lived up to expectations so far, struggling at times both in coverage and in tackling.
ST:
Duquesne has rotated three different punters with mixed results. Kicker Matt Marcinko is 1-for-1 on field goals, with a long of 35 yards.
Akron Notes:
Through three games, right guard K. Davis and right tackle King have graded out as the top performers on offense, while linebacker Cooper holds the highest mark on defense. Cooper also leads the team in tackles.
Defensive end Dall and defensive tackle Laventure have been credited with six pressures a piece. No one else has more than three. Dall also has three passes defended which is as much as anyone in the secondary.
On Zips Weekly, Moorhead attributed the missed field goals to protection issues.
My view on this game hasn’t really shifted since the preseason. Duquesne isn’t the same team they were a year ago, but we’ll still need to play well to win.
-
1
-
-
-
-
QB:
Finley had his best game of the season, though that might not be saying a whole lot after the first two. He avoided turnovers and made a handful of really nice throws. There were a few sacks I thought he could’ve steered clear of, but beyond that, if he can consistently play at this level, the offense has a chance to keep moving forward. I’m still scratching my head over why Johnson didn’t get any looks in short-yardage situations.
RB:
I kept waiting for Patrick to bust a big one, but it just never came. Still, he and Gant ran hard, combining for 148 yards on 20 carries. I’ll take that any day of the week.
WR:
Similar to Finley, this was the wide receiver corps’ best outing too. Even with three drops, they got open, put in effort blocking, and for the most part, hauled in the catches.
TE:
Newell didn’t do much with his two catches, but he was solid as a blocker, especially in pass protection. Cravaack saw less than 10 snaps.
OL:
I thought Lyons and K. Davis played well. There were a few times we were close to breaking a big run, but things like letting a combo block go too early and both guys releasing to the second level ended up giving the defender a free shot at the back. I can’t help but wonder if all the subbing we’re doing is causing some of those mistakes. The OL definitely could’ve been better at times, but overall they opened some holes and gave Finley a pocket to work with.
DL:
The defense as a whole did a really nice job against the run. That said, our four-man pass rush was anemic…again. We had a hard time getting pressure in the first half, though things looked a little better after the break. Both of our sacks came on five-man pressures if I’m not mistaken. I’m not sure what’s going on with Cheatom, he hasn’t played lately, and we’re getting next to nothing from the backup DEs.
LB:
I thought Cooper, Spriggs, and Boswell all played well. The more I watch Boswell, the more I like him—kid’s going to be a player and just has a knack for making things happen.
DB:
All things considered, I thought Reed and DeWalt held their own. Our safeties, on the other hand, got absolutely roasted when they were stuck in man during the first half. The good news is we probably won’t see a better passing attack the rest of the way. UAB may not be a great team overall, but they’ve got some legitimate threats at receiver.
ST:
The kickoff return for a touchdown and the penalty that set up another score were absolute back breakers and, in my opinion, the difference in the game. Punting and placekicking were solid otherwise, with the only miss coming on a long field goal attempt.
Coaching:
That was the most animated I’ve seen Moorhead since he’s been at Akron. I think he knew this was a game we had every chance to win, and maybe he’s feeling a little pressure too. I did like the commitment to the run game, and the offense putting up 441 yards without a turnover is nothing to scoff at. Sure, it came against a bad defense, but the offense still played well.
I’m not sure what adjustments were made defensively at halftime since I couldn’t see much of what was happening in the backend, but it was night and day when it came to points allowed. We still gave up yards, but that’s fine because at the end of the day the defense threw a second-half shutout.
In the end, it’s another disappointing close loss in the Moorhead era. The game was there for the taking, and we couldn’t do it. We’re likely going to be 1-3 heading into conference play, which is the exact same as last year’s payday schedule. Of course, that’s assuming we take care of Duquesne this weekend, who will surely be pining for an upset.
QB:
Finley
Johnson
RB:
Patrick
Gant
WR:
Walker
Mason
WR:
M. Williams
Monteiro
WR:
Polk
Grear
TE:
Newell
Cravaack
LT:
Motley-Simmons
D. Johnson
LG:
Archer
McManus
C
Lyons
Morris
RG:
K. Davis
RT:
A. Jones
King
DE:
Durham
D. Frazier
DE:
Dall
J. Frazier
DT:
Laventure
Mixon
DT:
Hull
Murphy
Musika
LB:
Cooper
Spriggs
LB:
Summers
Boswell
NB:
AL. Branch
AI. Branch
CB:
Reed
CB:
DeWalt
T. Thomas
S:
J. Anderson
Hunter
S:
D. Johnson
Flowers
KO:
Wiley
B. Johnson
K:
Wiley
P:
Castle
Top Rated Offense (20 snap minimum)
QB - Finley
WR - Grear
RG - K. Davis
WR - Polk
RT - King
Top Rated Defense (20 snap minimum)
DT - Murphy
NB - AL. Branch
LB - Spriggs
DE -Dall
DT - Laventure
-
2
-
2
-
-
Don’t turn it over, actually win the turnover battle, rack up 441 yards of offense, and still find a way to lose. Rough.
-
1
-
-
Shocked UAB didn’t run another screen there.
-
Please do not throw the ball here….
-
1
-
-
2 minutes ago, exit322 said:
I wouldn't be surprised to see that targeting call reversed so that he doesn't miss the first half. The hit on Finley wasn't targeting.
I’m being a little facetious. It’s been called inconsistently ever since it was implemented.
-
1 minute ago, exit322 said:
It wasn't forcible contact to the head/neck area using the helmet, forearm, hand, fist, elbow, or shoulder.
Vandy player got ejected tonight for less of a hit than that and had helmet up. I’m at a loss.
-
Not sure how that wasn’t flagged for targeting. Guess I just don’t understand the rule anymore.
-
6 minutes ago, exit322 said:
Akron's in this game, but they gotta score touchdowns against this offense.
Going to need to score just about every drive and hope UAB goofs up somewhere.
Game #6 CMU @ Akron - 3:30 pm October 3rd: Catdaddyp July Preview → Official Game Thread
in Akron Zips Football
Posted
Not disagreeing with you, but to be fair, that’s pretty much every team’s message board. Just look around the MAC — heading into this week’s game, CMU fans were talking about a possible 6-2 conference finish. After the loss, the tone completely flipped on their coaches and players. WMU fans were ready to run everyone out of town until they slipped past Toledo. NIU fans are calling for their coach’s job after nearly every loss. It’s just the nature of fanbases.
I’ve said this before, but as far as not being bowl eligible — don’t be so sure that sticks if we somehow get to six wins. The NCAA is becoming more toothless by the day.