To add dynamics, how about possibility of Can't, Buffalo, and Ball State all on Akron side?
Ball State should beat NIU at home. BGSU would probably be favored to beat Buffalo at home. Toledo has good chance to win at EMU. If so, you have:
#5 Ball State (8-8)
#6 BGSU (7-9) Based on 2-1 head-to-head record vs. Buff/EMU
#7 EMU (7-9) Based on 1-1 record vs. BG/Buff
#8 Buffalo (7-9) Based on 1-2 record vs. BG/EMU
Buffalo would be buried and need 3 wins to get to Semi's, but they'll have an easy home game (probably CMU), then have to beat Ball State, and then Can't. Fortunately, only one survives to play Akron, but the tournament is often a matter of who gets hot and there are a few players on those teams that can get hot. Ball State's won 6 of last 7 (make it 7 of 8 after NIU game) including beating WMU twice. Cant's won 6 of 7 and has likely 1st team MAC player Evans. And, of course, the Buffalo loss.