I thought 'Tino turned into the much better player but KD was infatuated w/ Noah.
During Noah's freshman season I was too. I'd never seen a true freshman PG come in and have such command of the game. Unfortunately, I don't think Noah was ever half the player he was as a freshman after suffering that knee injury.
If given the choice between the two I'd pick 'Tino. Especially if Coach Groce wants to pressure & run. Not a style seemingly fit for Noah's game, but perfect for 'Tino.