I saw Mahaffey play in high school & he's legit. 6'5" & athletic. But there's no way that as a true freshman he was grading out higher in practice than anyone on the team, is there?
Speaking of Mahaffey, I was going to mention that we're going to have two tall, athletic guards next year in Mahaffey and Josh Henderson (though Josh will only be true freshman). Both athletic 6'5" guards. Josh can shoot the lights out.
With one more off season of work I think Amani will be a great Stretch 4 next year. Perhaps 1st Team All-MAC good.