I don't love the move, but I understand it. As I said yesterday, I would prefer to give him another year, but his record thus far is hard to argue against. I believe the ineptness of Akron's administration is at least partially to blame for us having to start over again. I truly don't believe Arth would be playing this many underclassman if he knew he would only have 2.5 years to show major improvement. He took the long game approach, and he likely did that due to expectations discussed with Larry Williams. There were also a lot of factors that made it more difficult for him, some he's responsible for and some not. Arth seems like a good guy. Best of luck to him.
Many on here who have spent time with Guthrie speak highly of him. I sure as hell hope he gets it right. I do think Arth has established a foundation. We will likely lose a lot of players. Some that won't really hurt the program, but some will definitely hurt. There are also players who aren't showing much yet who will be really nice contributors for the program down the road. We need to get the new coach hired ASAP to build/salvage relationships where deemed necessary and to put together a recruiting class that is already falling apart. We want to avoid the Year zero sort of situation Arth had as a result of being hired so late in the process. Luckily for us, the MAC loses a lot of talent next year as a result of graduation, but we do not. We can also now bring in a max of 32 scholarship players. 25 regular counters and up to an additional 7 for players who enter the transfer portal on their own. We already have Blunt and Petereson there, so we'll definitely hit the 7 with the change in leadership. If all of the above is executed (hiring the right guy early, keeping the talent we have on the team, getting a solid class, and utilizing the transfer portal appropriately), we should be flirting with bowl eligibility next season. My expectations aren't any different than what they would have been for Arth. This should not be a complete tear down. For better or worse, there is no patience in college football.