Can you share the link to the UTC message board?
Arth doesn't appear to be a slam dunk on paper, and I would like a better understanding of the drop off (if there is an explanation). In my reading, it may be in part due to him not having his JCU OC, which he just got back. Arth was on the verge of making JCU a Mount Union level program, and nobody has had an issue with the thought of Kehres. He's been a QB in the NFL. He's shown to be able to recruit, at least at the FCS level. There can be a learning curve moving up. Arth at the least has shown improvement.
I haven't seen any slam dunk on paper. The board's favorite (I suspect because he played and was successful here) isn't that great either. No prior HC experience and the offense regressed under him, and that offense doesn't appear on paper to be a fun one to watch. I'm willing to listen, research, and give anyone a chance as long as they have some qualifications, because we aren't going to get some surefire guy like OSU. I hope the rest of the board and fan base is willing to do the same.