I'm uncertain as to which Akron 1 post you are referring?
Is it the one where he tells about an unsourced story he heard that UA has to honor each players four year scholarship.
Or is it the one where he incorrectly responds to your question “does that mean if a kid quits, or is dismissed from the team, or enters the portal but chooses to return to UA - but not on a football basis - is the scholarship still honored?”.
I'll guess it's the second one. If a kid quits (even if he stays in school) or enters and exits the portal (even if he stays in school) he gives up the scholarship and what I said previously applies. Being dismissed from the team is a little more tricky. A few years back, we had a scholarship guard on the basketball team who was cut from the team and tossed out of the university. Seems the authorities frowned on his business - selling pot. He lost his scholarship. On the other hand, A coach with a heart (which means this option may not be all that common) might elect to continue a players renewable scholarship despite the fact that the coach cut the player from the team solely because the player wasn't good enough. You prove to me that any player on the Akron team has a guaranteed 4 year scholarship and then we will address that.